↓ Skip to main content

Team seminars

PhD defense

The gendered order of journalism: a mixed and computational approach to gender inequalities in French print media content

PhD candidate
Ange Richard (PACTE / LIG (GETALP))
Date
Room
Sciences Po Grenoble (IEP), Quermonne room (ground floor), 1030 avenue Centrale, 38400 Saint-Martin-d'Hères

Original title: L’ordre genré du journalisme. Une approche mixte et computationnelle des inégalités de genre dans les contenus de presse écrite française.

PhD thesis in sociology, supervised by Gilles Bastin (PACTE laboratory) and François Portet (Laboratoire d’Informatique de Grenoble). The defense will be held in French. A reception will follow in the building’s hall.

The defense will also be streamed online. To get the link, and to confirm your attendance (on site or remotely) and/or at the reception, please fill in this form.

Jury
#

  • Florence Le Cam, Professor, Université libre de Bruxelles (Reviewer)
  • Étienne Ollion, CNRS Research Director, École polytechnique (Reviewer)
  • Roselyne Ringoot, Professor, Université Grenoble Alpes
  • Aurélie Olivesi, Associate Professor, Université Lyon 1
  • David Doukhan, Researcher, Institut national de l’audiovisuel
  • Gilles Bastin, Professor, Université Grenoble Alpes (Thesis Director)
  • François Portet, Professor, Université Grenoble Alpes (Invited Thesis Director)

Abstract
#

Abstract translated from French.

This thesis examines how gender inequalities are produced in press discourse, from the point of view of content and of its producers, journalists. The analysis draws on two prestigious French newsrooms that have introduced editorial policies against gender inequalities in their output: the Agency, a major news agency, and the Pureplayer, an online news outlet.

One of the thesis’s main contributions lies in its mixed and computational methodology. It combines a qualitative study of 30 interviews conducted in 2021 and 2022 within the two case studies with the application of natural language processing tools to a corpus of about 2.2 million articles produced by the two newsrooms. To analyse these data, I propose three indicators of inequality in articles: the masculinity rate of mentions, the masculinity rate of quotations, and the stereotyped use of reporting verbs. These indicators are computed on the corpora with machine-learning-based algorithms developed during the thesis.

The analysis first reveals a tension: the profession’s recognition of gender inequalities in media content has not led to a lasting change in imbalances observed for several decades. The first part of the manuscript analyses the organisational and editorial changes made by the two case studies between 2016 and 2021, then the evolution of gender inequalities in the content they produced since 1984 (for the Agency) and 2008 (for the Pureplayer). I describe how gender issues became a “professional problem” within journalism, giving rise to “feminist interventions” in newsrooms. Despite this, I show the regularity of masculinity and the gendered assignment phenomena that persist in journalistic discourse.

The second part of the thesis seeks to understand why these inequalities are so constant and evolve so slowly. I explain this inertia by the persistence of professional routines that (re)produce a gendered “system of exclusion” (Foucault, 1971) in media discourse. I show that adopting practices that reduce gender imbalances depends on professional routines specific to journalistic work and to the organisation of work in each newsroom. The Agency and the Pureplayer are two cases more or less favourable to changing journalistic routines, although both adhere to routines typical of the profession, such as the pursuit of objectivity. Finally, I show that the profession’s attachment to a dominant paradigm of objectivity reproduces and maintains a gendered order of media discourse. The thesis thus makes an empirical contribution to the feminist critique of objectivity by applying it to French journalism. Through its methodology, it also opens an epistemological reflection on the use of algorithms in the study of gender relations.